Choose Pilates With Amanda if
- You specifically want Prenatal Pilates. Rolates Pilates does not list it.
- You can only get there after work. This is the one with classes after 6pm.
Pilates With Amanda vs Rolates Pilates
At twice a week, Rolates Pilates works out $880 a month cheaper on 10 group class package, and Pilates With Amanda teaches Prenatal Pilates and Rolates Pilates teaches Cadillac Pilates. Both are Pilates studios in New York, NY, which is what makes them worth putting side by side. Everything below comes from what each studio publishes, and every figure carries the date we last checked it.
How often would you go?
Every price below is recalculated as the cheapest published way to buy that many classes at each studio, packs and memberships included.
Pilates With Amanda does not publish a drop in price, so it cannot be costed against the rest. Call before you go.
The short answers
- Cheapest at twice a weekRolates Pilates$320 a month, $880 less than the next cheapest, via 10 group class package.
- Only one with private sessionsRolates PilatesRolates Pilates is the only studio here that lists private sessions. The others may still offer it, we have not recorded that they do.
- Only one with reformer equipmentRolates PilatesRolates Pilates is the only studio here that lists reformer equipment. The others may still offer it, we have not recorded that they do.
- Only one with a beginner trackPilates With AmandaPilates With Amanda is the only studio here that lists a beginner track. The others may still offer it, we have not recorded that they do.
| What is being compared |  Pilates With AmandaUpper East Side, New York, NY |  Rolates PilatesHell's Kitchen, New York, NY |
|---|---|---|
| What it costs youPriced for twice a week. Change the routine above and every figure recalculates. | ||
| Cost of twice a weekThe cheapest published way to buy this many classes at each studio, including packs and memberships. | $1,200 a monthEstimated from the published ratechecked 13 days ago | $320 a monthLowestEstimated from the published ratechecked 13 days ago |
| Cheapest way to pay | 10 private session package$150 a class at this rate | 10 group class package$40 a class at this rate |
| Drop in class | Not listed | $45checked 13 days ago |
| First month with the intro offerWhat a new client pays in month one. Almost always cheaper than the ongoing rate, and it is the number most comparisons leave out. | $1,150Intro offer plus 7 more classeschecked 13 days ago | $410LowestIntro offer plus 5 more classeschecked 13 days ago |
| Membership beats drop in atGo more often than this and the membership is the cheaper option. | Not listed | Not listed |
| Membership from | Not listed | Not listed |
| Unlimited membership | Not listed | Not listed |
| Private session | $165checked 13 days ago | $120Lowestchecked 13 days ago |
| Semi private session | $250checked 13 days ago | $70Lowestchecked 13 days ago |
| Classes and equipment | ||
| Class styles taught | Prenatal Pilates, Private Pilates
| Cadillac Pilates, Chair Pilates, Mat Pilates, Private Pilates, Reformer Pilates, Tower Pilates
|
| Equipment | Not listed | Reformer, Tower, Cadillac, Wunda Chair, Chair, Barrel, Mat
|
| How you can train | Not listed | Group classes, Private sessions
|
| Levels taught | Beginner, Advanced
| Not listed |
| When you can go | ||
| Classes before 7amA blank means we have not recorded it, not that there are none. | Not listed | Not listed |
| Classes after 6pm | Yes | Not listed |
| Weekend classes | Not listed | Not listed |
| Schedule last updated | Not listed | Not listed |
| The studio itself | ||
| Rating on GoogleRatings and review counts come from Google, not from us. | 5.0 out of 5Highest40 Google reviews | 4.8 out of 512 Google reviews |
| Reviews on Google | 40Highest | 12 |
| Where it is | Upper East Side, New York | Hell's Kitchen, New York |
| Amenities | Not listed | Not listed |
| Accessibility | Not listed | Not listed |
| Books online | Not listed | Yes |
| How current this is | ||
| Listing statusListed means imported public data. Claimed means the owner proved control. Verified means we checked the details. | Listed | Listed |
| Prices last checked | 13 days ago | 13 days ago |
| Listing last verified | 13 days ago | 13 days ago |
| Go there | See the full profileCall (917) 650-0808 | See the full profileBook a class |
Prices are what each studio published when we last checked, and each one shows that date. Ratings and review counts come from Google. A blank cell means we have not recorded that detail, not that the studio does not offer it.
Which one is for you
Choose Rolates Pilates if
- Money is the deciding factor. At twice a week you would pay $320 a month here against $1,200, and the cheapest route is 10 group class package.
- You want the cheapest way to try it once. The intro offer puts month one at $410: three private sessions, $210.
- You specifically want Cadillac Pilates, Chair Pilates, Mat Pilates. Pilates With Amanda does not list those.
- Equipment matters to you. Rolates Pilates lists Reformer, Tower, Cadillac and Pilates With Amanda does not.
Where they are the same
These are the rows both studios answer identically, so they are not worth spending your decision on.
- Cheapest way to pay10 private session package
- Listing statusListed
- Prices last checked13 days ago
- Listing last verified13 days ago
Questions people ask about these two
- Which is cheaper, Pilates With Amanda or Rolates Pilates?
- At twice a week, Rolates Pilates works out at $320 a month through 10 group class package, against $1,200 at Pilates With Amanda. Go less often and the gap narrows, because the cheapest route changes with frequency.
- What does the first month cost at Pilates With Amanda or Rolates Pilates?
- Pilates With Amanda works out at $1,150 on its intro private lesson, $100, and Rolates Pilates at $410 on its three private sessions, $210. Intro offers are for new clients and normally run out after a set number of classes, so the first month is not what the following months cost.
- Do Pilates With Amanda and Rolates Pilates teach the same classes?
- Both teach Private Pilates. Pilates With Amanda lists Prenatal Pilates, while Rolates Pilates lists Cadillac Pilates, Chair Pilates, Mat Pilates, Reformer Pilates, Tower Pilates. Studios do add and drop styles between terms, so check the current timetable before you buy a pack for one style.
- Which has better reviews, Pilates With Amanda or Rolates Pilates?
- Pilates With Amanda holds 5.0 out of 5 from 40 Google reviews and Rolates Pilates holds 4.8 from 12. Those are Google's ratings, not ours. Review counts follow how long a studio has been open as much as how good it is, so read the recent ones rather than the average.
- How current are these prices?
- Pilates With Amanda: prices checked 13 days ago. Rolates Pilates: prices checked 13 days ago. Every figure on this page carries the date it was last confirmed, and we would rather show you an old date than let an old price pass for a current one.